With eco-guilt being the new catholicism, I feel like even bringing this up is some kind of blasphemy.
But every black cloud has a silver lining right?
This article would seem to be at odds with a previous one in The Walrus:
http://www.walrusmagazine.com/articles/2007.10.10-alphabet-city-discussion-two-eat-local/
If the emphasis is to be increasingly placed on "local", what is the point of "opening" the Northwest Passage?
I frankly find reprehensible your suggestion that the opening of the Northwest passage is an advantage of global warming.
The notion that mankind can offer better solutions to the planet than nature is arrogant in the extreme.
The human race has already inflicted enormous harm on our planet, to the point where our future is uncertain. So how can you even put the fortunes of commerce ahead of the struggle to save our planet?
Personally, I find this article presents and interesting juxtaposition. It is true that mankind has cause enormous harm to the planet and is responsible for much of the environmental turmoil we see today; however, as the article points out, opening the NWP to shipping has the potential to significantly reduce the seaborne pollution that we dump into our oceans ever year. I certainly disagree that this article presents a reprehensible point of view - it is really just trying to present a way of looking at the glass half full while us humans try to figure a way out of the mess we have created.
"...opening the NWP to shipping has the potential to significantly reduce the seaborne pollution that we dump into our oceans ever year."
Rather, the seaborne pollution would likely be transferred to the (still, and for quite a while to come) more fragile environment of the Arctic Islands and Ocean.......
Opening the Northwest Passage will infringe on Canada's Arctic sovereignty. Not to mention the fact that the U.S., Russia and the E.U. do not respect Canada's claim to the sea route.
Does the Canadian government need to assert its control over the waterway? And how so?
"Does the Canadian government need to assert its control over the waterway? And how so?"
Well, first Harper promised to build 3 armed, military icebreakers, plus a deep sea port.....
Now, he promises to build eight patrol boats, a training base, and a deepsea port......
There will doubtless be other promises......
The openning of the Northwest Passage will be an economic boon much sooner than expected as a result of things changing faster than conservative scientific prediction. It's unfortunate that these economics are viewed in isolation and not balanced with the real costs of millions of lives lost to sea level rise and rapid changes to general climatic conditions. Looks like deja vue...industrial revolution, all over again!
You can show your support for global warming by joining the Walrus sponsored cruise of the Artic - each passenger is guaranteed to contribute 5.6 tonnes of CO2 over the course of a 10 day cruise. Act quickly - this is a once in a lifetime opportunity.