Skip to content
Click on cover to enlarge

Unsafe Practices

«  page 1 of 2  »

Can the Masai reconcile tradition with the realities of HIV?

by Alanna Mitchell

Published in the April 2008 issue.  » BUY ISSUE     

Bookmark and Share             Facebook         Stumble      Get The Walrus on your Blackberry or Windows Mobile        RSS


I knew of the Masai long before I met them. They were the majestic warriors of the East African savannah, their bodies so thin and tall they barely cast a shadow in the scorching sun. They were the romance of humanity’s birth continent, among the few on the planet who still live by ancient rites the rest of us have long forgotten. So when I learned recently that the modern scourge of hiv/aids might wipe them out, it seemed important to travel to their lands on the edges of the teeming Serengeti.

It was my honeymoon. My husband and I landed in the north of Tanzania, near Mount Kilimanjaro, and made our way to the village of Mto wa Mbu (“mosquito river” in Swahili), where Charles Luoga of the Institute of Cultural Affairs, a non-governmental organization, has set up one of the few programs in East Africa to deal specifically with aids and the Masai.

We could hardly wait for our first glimpse of the iconic tribespeople, and it wasn’t long in coming, only a few hours from the airport at a handy roadside attraction set up for tourists like us. About a dozen Masai women dressed in red, neck hoops bouncing up and down on their chests, danced and sang a song about their “Masai market.” We posed with them, took pictures, and bought jewellery. Astonishingly, all of the women wore beaded hiv/aids pins.

Mto wa Mbu is down a new paved road, just a few kilometres from Olduvai Gorge, the fabled site where Mary Leakey unearthed fossil remains of some of the world’s oldest human ancestors. The Masai don’t live in the town, Luoga explained. Rather, clustered in boma, groups of mud and thatch homes spread out on the wind-torn plains that surround it.

It’s impossible to know how many Masai live in Monduli, the district that includes Mto wa Mbu, or, for that matter, how many altogether inhabit Tanzania and Kenya. Estimates range from 600,000 to over a million. Draped in red shawls, Masai men roam between the two countries in search of grazing land for their thirsty herds of cattle, keep to themselves, and are often missed by government statistics gatherers. Indeed, while there are examples of certain communities embracing change (e.g., the adoption of Christian burial practices), for the Masai in general, traditions and age-old cultural practices tend to be adhered to. Around Mto wa Mbu, all but the most critically endangered babies are born on the boma, and the dead, according to Luoga, are ritually put into the bush for the hyenas. (If the hyenas are not quick enough, Luoga said, the Masai smear the bodies of their dead with goat fat to attract them.) There are no official records of births, deaths, or local population size.

It’s also difficult to determine how many are affected by hiv/aids. Dr. A. S. Swai, a former medical officer of health for the Monduli district, told me that about 14 percent of all tribespeople in Monduli are hiv positive, roughly twice the Tanzanian average. He could only guess at the number of hiv-positive Masai, but there are troubling stories that they might be especially vulnerable, perhaps even catastrophically so.

As we drove back to Mto wa Mbu, Luoga pointed to a group of huts in the distance. Each boma is the household of an extended family, and the number of huts roughly indicates how many wives the patriarch has. Most have several. The richest have a dozen. Luoga knew of one who had twenty. Masai men pride themselves on having enough wives to share with others in their age group, both locally and from other Masai land, and some Masai women also have lovers. As a result, Masai often have dozens of sex partners, putting them at considerable risk of contracting hiv. Many Masai girls become sexually active when they are just seven or eight years old, so it’s possible some will become infected and die before they can bear their own children.

The next day, we arrive at the turquoise-walled courtyard of the Institute of Cultural Affairs in Mto wa Mbu to meet some of Luoga’s local volunteers. (Naseriani Mollen, a Masai woman, walked twelve kilometres to attend.) Some are hiv positive; others keep promising to be tested. However, while antiretroviral drugs are free in Tanzania, they don’t seem to be reaching the Masai: only one person in this group is taking the drugs.

Samuel Laizer, with holes the size of silver dollars in his earlobes and, like many Masai, missing his left front tooth — a precaution against lockjaw, to allow an entry point for herbal medicines from traditional healers — told us that many Masai don’t believe hiv/aidscan affect them. There is increasing awareness of the disease, but a general reluctance to take necessary precautions, if these are even available. Masai men, for instance, are vehemently opposed to using condoms. Laizer described visiting a family nursing a sick relative, probably in the advanced stages of aids. The wife met Laizer at the entrance to her boma and told him her husband was asleep. When he returned the next day, she offered the same reason. On the third day, he snuck into the boma and witnessed a witch doctor making circles around the husband’s head with a chicken. Within a week, the man died from lack of food and water. He had not been attended to because his family thought he was bewitched.

It can be tough to get treatment in this part of Africa, even if you admit you need it. Mto wa Mbu has the sole health centre in a ninety-kilometre radius, and only here can people get antiretroviral drugs. The centre is run by the Lutheran Church, and, with its sprinklers and planted flowers — all but unheard of in a district so dry that people and cattle drink from the same muddy ditches — it struck me as an oasis of sorts. On the day we visited, the doctor, Steven Mchau, and his staff were treating fifty-one patients with antiretrovirals. Not many were Masai, however; apparently, they tend to be on the point of death before they come to the clinic, if they come at all.

Comments (4 comments)

Carol: It is good.I appreciate your work. Thank you May 06, 2008 10:23 EST

Lauren Birks: Dear Editor,

This article is deeply disturbing to me, a person who has just spent several weeks working and living in the Ngorongoro Conservation Area with the Maasai community living in the area. I will also be returning over the next indefinite period of time to continue with research and to work with a local hospital that primarily treats and cares for the Maasai community.

I am a PhD student with the University of Calgary that is working on developing community-based prevention and education programs that address mother-to-child HIV transmission in the Maasai population. Alanna Mitchell clearly did not educate herself properly about the Maasai community in Northern Tanzania prior to visiting. She not only has spelled their name wrong (with only one "A"), but she has also failed to survey the Maasai communities in the surrounding areas regarding HIV/AIDS statistics, testing and care and treatment. She has made the fatal mistake of relying on the knowledge on only a few people in one community, where the Maasai do not even reside. Rather than accurately and effectively seeking out information from local hospitals that work with Maasai communities on a regular basis, such as Endulen Hospital in the Ngorongoro Conservation Area, she has simply shown up in one area where there is a relatively low population of Maasai residing and has not even attempted to learn about the culture beyond tourism and HIV.

I fear that such an uninformed article will only serve to exacerbate stigma about HIV/AIDS in the area, as well as to create an ill-informed group of potential visitors that will view the Maasai community in Northern Tanzania as an HIV-ridden society that does nothing but engage in female circumcision and sexual rituals. This view does not accurately portray the Maasai culture at all. They are an intelligent group of people that have fought very hard to maintain their cultural traditions and pastoralist lifestyle in spite of government efforts to move them out of their native habitat. They are a kind people, that need assistance with food security, health care and HIV/AIDS prevention, testing and treatment. If Alanna Mitchell had not generalized an unconfirmed/unverified statistic that HIV prevalence among the Maasai in Tanzania is at 14%, she would have discovered that actually the prevalence is closer to an approximate 2.5% currently.

While I am an avid reader of the Walrus, I cannot support such a politicized and incorrect piece of writing and I am disappointed with the education and research that this author clearly did NOT do. In addition, the nice final paragraph about her $170/night hotel room in Zanibar did nothing except to serve as a reminder of the all too common view that the "Western" person is able to fly in and out of a place and assess a situation accurately without taking into account disparities of wealth, inequalities, gender issues, accessibility issues, geographical issues, etc. I would hope that most readers will be able to see this article as a discriminatory and judgmental piece that falsely portrays the Maasai people of Tanzania.

Sincerely,

Lauren Birks
July 12, 2008 03:35 EST

erick ezekiel:
i think a good writter has got to be well informed before writting any topic.

the maasai peopple and their values should be respected like any other people in the world.

i think no manipulation or violation of peoples culture and values is accepted antwhere in the world. July 21, 2008 06:05 EST

Anonymous: I whole-heartedly agree with Lauren Birks that the author should have been more informed before writing this piece.

I am a Canadian citizen and I am married to a Tanzanian man I met while living in Tanzania 2 years ago. Even 2 years after being married I still consider myself to be far from an expert on Tanzanian culture and society. I think that there are a lot of assumptions built into this article, which perpetuate stereotypes. From what I know about Tanzania there are a number of mistruths in the article.

I am not at all surprised. In my experience western people often see what they wan to see when they are in Africa and come home first hand accounts of how their stereotypes were confirmed.

While there are maasai people who dress traditionally, I find her account of being met by maasai women in maasai jewellery selling their crafts, humorous. I have often seen “maasai people” dressed in traditional outfits having diner with delighted tourists only to see them at the bar later or walking down the street on their day off in a pair of jeans and a t-shirt.

I am greatly discouraged by the fact that people continue to view peoples of other countries as primitive and feel the need to pose with them to have photos taken as if they are some kind of cultural artefact rather than real human beings.

July 31, 2008 18:35 EST

Comment on this article


Will not be displayed on the site

Submit a comment online

Submit a letter to the Editor


    Cancel

The Walrus E-Newsletter

Online exclusives, events, offers:
get news of everything Walrus.


Article Tools

»    RSS Feed      Bookmark and Share

»  Printer-friendly page

»  Email this article

»  Comment on this article

»  More in this issue

»  More in Health

»  More from Alanna Mitchell

»  BUY THIS ISSUE

ADVERTISE WITH US